Indie Basement (5/16): the week in classic indie, alternative & college rock

This week: Billy Nomates, New Order, Ezra Furman, M(h)aol, Grails, The Gotobeds, Artificial Go, Klaus Johann Grobe offshoot Try & Harder, and more.

May 16, 2025 - 21:40
 0
Indie Basement (5/16): the week in classic indie, alternative & college rock

Happy mid-May to everyone. There’s no shortage of worthy new albums this week and I review seven of them, including underrated UK singer-songwriter Billy Nomates, strident Irish trio M(h)aol, The Gotobeds (first album in six years), Ezra Furman, Grails, post-punks Artificial Go, and new Swiss duo Try Harder which includes one half of Indie Basement all-stars Klaus Johann Grobe. This week’s Indie Basement Classic is my favorite New Order album (that turned 40 this week).

For more record reviews, check out Notable Releases where Andrew spins the latest from Friendship, Arm’s Length, The Callous Daoboys, Lido Pimienta and more.

Amongst this week’s news: former Savages frontperson Jehnny Beth announced her second solo album; No Joy have a new record on the way; and The Chameleons’ first album in 21 years will be out in August.

Plus: Supergrass’ debut album turned 30 this week. To misquote one of their songs, We are old!

Head below for this week’s reviews.

billy nomates - metalhorse

ALBUM OF THE WEEK #1: Billy Nomates – Metalhorse (Invada)
Tor Maries goes full-band on her wonderful third Billy Nomates album

Tor Maries found her life in tummolt following the release of, CACTI, her second album as Billy Nomates. She was receiving critical accolades, her creativity was still on the ascent but her personal life was getting more complicated, including caring for her father who was in the late stages of crippling Parkinson’s Disease. “From the second I started working on this album,” Tor says of her third album, “every other month has brought this massive life shift that has either been weirdly magical and brilliant, or quite the opposite.” She sought balance through music and poured the highs and lows into Metalhorse, her third album, which expands on her unique, signature mix of new wave, post-punk, and pop country. A few things changed this time around, most notably she used her band — bassist Mandy Clarke (KT Tunstall, The Go! Team) and drummer Liam Chapman (Rozi Plain, BMX Bandits) — in the studio for the first time, which makes these songs fuller, sharper, and hit harder.

It also takes her melodic style, centered around her rich voice and distinctive twangy harmonies, even further into folk/country territory. It’s a definite step up for her most confident, personal batch of songs yet which are framed around Metalhorse, a fictional amusement park where the rollercoaster of life is writ large in thrill rides. “If you want to jump out of the merry-go-round,” Tor sings on Metalhorse‘s title track, “there’s a way to go about it without tumbling down.” Piano and keyboards take more of a front seat here, giving “The Test” and “Life’s Unfair” more percussive oomph. She’s still writing the kind of immediately satisfying, belt-it-out earworms that you could imagine being hits for Shania Twain or LeAnn Rimes in the late-’90s — check out “Override” and “Plans” — which she imbues with her own mid-’80s production aesthetic that is reminiscent of Prefab Sprout or Strangeways-era Smiths. In that regard, don’t miss atmospheric, synthy ballad “My Darkhorse Friend,” which features former Stranglers frontman Hugh Cornwell’s signature baritone. Tor really feels like she’s come into her own with Metalhorse — she’s starting to use her own name more, professionally, too — as she white-knuckles one hairpin curve after another. “Some rides are nice to get on and some rides aren’t,” Maries says. “That’s how life felt for a minute, and it still feels like that a bit now.”

Metalhorse by Billy Nomates / Tor

mhaol something soft

ALBUM OF THE WEEK #2: M(h)aol – Something Soft (Merge)
There’s not much “soft” heard on this Dublin post-punk trio’s sharp-as-hell second album 

If you like your post-punk spare, disaffected, darkly funny, socially conscious and sharp as hell, few are doing it better in 2025 than Dublin trio M(h)aol. Their second album is an eviscerating slice to the gut, carved with smile while looking you in the eyes. The production, courtesy the band’s Jamie Hyland, is perfectly blown-out with lots of fantastic touches, from the vintage touch-tone-phone hook on “1-800-Call-Me-Back” to the atmospheric miasma of noise enveloping the brooding “Clementine” and the machine gun staccato effects on “I Miss My Dog” that Model/Actress would be envious of. The driving rhythm section’s clockwork precision is perfectly recorded, blown-out in all the right ways, and dares you not to dance. While much of the album is cut with humor, don’t think for a second M(h)aol aren’t serious about their causes, as the dread-filled playing of some songs make apparent. “Pursuit” is a harrowing yet compelling portrait of either an abusive relationship or a fraught late night walk home alone and “DM:AM” addresses unwanted attention of social media. Then there’s “Snare” that looks at subtle misogyny in the music industry and give the album its title. “Why not play something soft like piano or violin?” a man asks at the merch table. “I know now what I didn’t know at nine / You’re talking shit and you’re wasting your own time.” Soft doesn’t suit M(h)aol. “It’s meant to sound like that!”

Something Soft by M(h)aol

artificial go - musical chairs

Artificial Go – Musical Chairs (Feel It Records)
No this is not a lost gem from the original post-punk era, but a new record from Cincinnati

Artificial Go are the finest late-’70s Scandinavian post-punk band to ever come out of 2020s Cincinnati. Angie Willcutt’s accent drifts across Europe, the UK, New York and Southern California, sometimes even within a single song, like “Circles,” which sounds like a gene-splicing of Liliput, The Waitresses and Moon Unit Zappa. Before I go on to reference more vintage obscure bands, I will just say I think Musical Chairs, a title that perhaps references the many styles on display here, is awesome. You will too if you dig that era of music and/or are a regular reader of this column. The album sounds like an unearthed cassette from 1980, the lost debut of a band who disappeared in the Swiss Alps under mysterious circumstances, and people who remember them cannot be sure now if they actually existed. Songs are, at turns, jangly, jagged, stiffly funky, manic, twitchy, and very catchy. Other touchpoints; The Feelies, Suburban Lawns, Grauzone, Delta Five, The Monochrome Set. Only a lyrical reference to a Labradoodle gives Musical Chairs away as an ingenious, very entertaining fake.

Musical Chairs by Artificial Go

Ezra Furman_Goodbye Small Head

Ezra Furman – Goodbye Small Head (Bella Union)
Furman’s “orchestral emo prog-rock record sprinkled with samples” is one of her best.

Ezra Furman notes that her new album Goodbye Small Head was written with William Wordsworth’s famous proclamation that “Poetry is the spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings: it takes its origin from emotion recollected in tranquility” in mind. “I can agree with that, except for the tranquility part,” Eza says. “This poetry, my poetry, arrived in the midst of the storm.” In whatever circumstances these songs burst out and were caught by microphones and recording equipment, it captures Ezra and her band at their most ambitious and creative; a genre-spanning concept album that works whether you realize it’s that or not thanks to fantastic songwriting, performances and modern arrangements. “If I were a music journalist, I would call this an orchestral emo prog-rock record sprinkled with samples,” Ezra writes in the album’s press notes. “Thank goodness I’m not a music journalist!” I dunno, Ezra, I think you do pretty well in that regard. The samples on Goodbye Small Head (the title is a Sleater-Kinney reference) pull things out of the millenium era into now without ever calling attention to themselves. It’s just really well produced, never lacking in guts or heart as Ezra weighs in on life, death, love, strengths and weaknesses, and all the other Big Stuff. Heavy and joyous all at the same time, Goodbye Small Head is one of Ezra’s best.

Goodbye Small Head by Ezra Furman

GOTOBEDS_MASTERCLASS_COVER

The Gotobeds – Masterclass (12XU)
The first album in six years from these Pittsburgh punk smartasses is their best in a decade.

When last we heard from Pittsburgh smartasses The Gotobeds, 2019, they had just delivered their second album for Sub Pop, Debt Begins at 30, which was loaded with cool guests including members of Pavement and Protomartyr. I’m not sure it was loaded with their best songs, though. The band’s tenure on Sub Pop never quite worked; they seemed like an ’80s punk band who reluctantly signed to a major and spent the whole time proving they were still the same band they were before. I don’t dislike either album they made for Sub Pop (the first being 2016’s Blood // Sugar // Secs // Traffic) but both were notably missing the bratty exuberance and constant barrage of hooky, snotty songs found on 2014’s awesome Poor People Are Revolting. They have now parted ways with Sub Pop and are back on 12XU, the label run by Matador cofounder Gerard Cosloy who put out PPAR. Also back, I’m happy to report: the magic. Masterclass is ripper after ripper that mix post-punk, post-hardcore, pure punk, Pittsburgh and other P words with big hooks, unfakeable energy, and attitude that compliments, not overpowers, what’s on tape. Sporting a new lineup of the band, The Gotobeds sound invigorated and alive, like someone who’s finally out of a bad relationship and are finally unleashing all the good stuff — and anger — they’ve been keeping inside. Sonics are thick and noisy, with lots of sludge, ragged solos and snot. Welcome back, boys.

Masterclass by The Gotobeds

grails - miracle music

Grails – Miracle Music (Temporary Residence Ltd)
Ninth album from Emil Amos and Alex Hall’s long-running experimental group is another satisfying cinematic head trip

Over the last 25 years, Portland’s Grails have transformed from a rock band with experimental, avant-garde and cinematic ambitions into something much more wide-ranging and hard to pin down. They’re still led by Emil Amos and Alex Hall but Miracle Music, their ninth album, owes as much to Boards of Canada and Ulrich Schnauss as Godspeed You! Black Emperor and Earth. This is as lush, dark and mysterious as the deepest parts of a vast Pacific Northwest forest, thick with atmospheric sound design where shards of light only occasionally reach the mossy floor. Sonically, this is an impressive achievement with dazzlingly layered arrangements of electronic wizardry and organic instrumentation (including gorgeous horn parts courtesy Kelly Pratt). When the album crescendos with the magisterial “Strange Paradise,” you’ve cleared the trees, are passing through the stratosphere and heading out to other worlds. Is there a Dolby Atmos mix of this album? There should be – this is planetarium trip-out music of the highest order.

Miracle Music by Grails

try harder-EP

Try & Harder – Try Harder EP (Too Much Fun Records)
Debut EP from this Swiss duo including Klaus Johann Grobe’s Sevi Landolt is overflowing with good vibes and great basslines

Basel, Switzerland’s Try & Harder is the new duo of Sevi Landolt (Klaus Johann Grobe) and Nicolas Büttiker (Delorian Cloud Fire, Amuse Bouche) and if you’re familiar with their other groups you will probably not be surprised that they make dreamy and very groovy pop. Sevi brings the killer basslines, while Nicolas brings his vibraphone. Add in some Jaki Liebezeit-style drumming, lounge-disco rhythm guitar and spaced-out analog synths and you’ve got something I am going to love. Bliss out on these three tracks’ warm vibes.

Try & Harder by Try & Harder

new order low life

INDIE BASEMENT CLASSIC: New Order – Low-Life (Factory / Qwest, 1985)
‘Power, Corruption & Lies’ may be New Order’s most iconic album but this is, song-for-song, their best. 

I’ll let you in on a secret: I’m a huge New Order fan. Just a couple weeks ago I included their groundbreaking second album, Power, Corruption & Lies, as an Indie Basement Classic and I’m already back doing the same for it’s follow-up which turned 40 this week. Here’s a bit of my retrospective review:

What is the best New Order album? Consensus generally goes with 1983’s Power, Corruption & Lies, and it’s hard to argue with that. The dust had settled, Bernard Sumner had officially become the group’s lead vocalist, and their sound started to solidify. Peter Hook’s unusual bass style — played high on the neck, often mistaken for guitar — intertwined with Sumner’s snaky leads, while Morris kept the beat with a mix of disco and krautrock, all played with a watchmaker’s precision. Gilbert filled things out with atmospheric keyboards and guitar. Add to that their rapidly growing skill with technology — not to mention amazing songs like “Age of Consent,” “The Village,” “Your Silent Face,” and “Leave Me Alone” — and PC&L was such a level-up that it’s hard to deny its place at the top of the rankings.

But Low-Life, which came almost exactly a year later, is just as good—and in many ways, better. No other New Order album blends both sides of their sound — electronic and rock — with one eye on their beginnings and the rest of the body aimed at the future. While the albums that followed would more often than not have songs that were either “rock” or “synth,” Low-Life let things intermingle in wonderful and surprising ways. They were an unstoppable creative force, and the album features some of their best-known songs, but also some of their finest deep cuts, making for what is arguably the most richly satisfying album of their career — one that can still surprise you 40 years later.

Read the whole feature here.

Looking for more? Browse the Indie Basement archives.

And check out what’s new in our shop.

The 20 Best Britpop Albums of 1995