I tried on similar blazers at Old Navy and Banana Republic. The 2 were very different in both quality and price.

I tried on and compared similar blazers at Old Navy and Banana Republic. Both were nice, but there was a clear winner in terms of quality and value.

Mar 10, 2025 - 19:38

I tried on similar blazers at Old Navy and Banana Republic. The 2 were very different in both quality and price.

A composite image of Chloe wearing two black blazers with front pockets. — I tried on blazers at Old Navy and Banana Republic.
Chloe Caldwell

I tried on similar blazers at two Gap Inc.-owned retailers: Old Navy and Banana Republic.
The blazers were very different in terms of price and quality.
Despite being $110 more expensive, I'd consider investing in the version from Banana Republic.

A chic blazer is a true wardrobe staple. Whether it's for professional settings, street style, or elevating casual outfits, a blazer is one of the most versatile pieces someone can have in their closet.

After years of wearing the same black blazer I found at a thrift store, I decided it was time for an upgrade. So, I turned to two trusted retailers for basics: Old Navy and Banana Republic, both owned by Gap Inc.

Here's how my search for the perfect blazer went.

I started at Old Navy because of the retailer's approachable prices.

The exterior of an Old Navy store. — Old Navy (location I visited not pictured) has over 1,200 locations around the world.
Robert V Schwemmer/Shutterstock

Since opening its first store in 1994, Old Navy has become one of the world's largest apparel brands. Today, the company has over 1,200 stores around the world.

Although I'm not usually drawn to major corporations, I know I can always count on Old Navy to offer classic and trending pieces at an affordable price.

I wasn't blown away by the blazer I tried on at Old Navy.

Chloe wearing a black blazer with two front pockets over a black shirt. — I thought the shoulder pads were a bit too prominent.
Chloe Caldwell

When I arrived at the store, I browsed the racks and headed to the fitting room with the Taylor relaxed suit blazer in black. I liked the style and fit, but there were a few big turnoffs for me.

I thought the shoulder pads were stylish, but they were sticking out slightly to the point that there was a noticeable outline. This was a sign to me that the blazer lacked quality of construction.

I also appreciate a trendy oversize silhouette, but there was no shape or cinching at the waist, making me look boxy.

Plus, the blazer was made entirely of synthetic materials, including 91% polyester and 9% spandex.

Although these flaws were subtle, I wouldn't pay $50 for this blazer. I'd rather invest in one that's well-structured and flattering.

I continued my search for a new blazer at Banana Republic, Gap Inc.'s destination for attainable luxury.

The exterior of a Banana Republic store in a mall. — Banana Republic (location I visited not pictured) has over 400 locations around the world.
JHVEPhoto/Shutterstock

Founded in 1978, Banana Republic is known for elevated and classic styles. Today, the brand has over 400 locations around the world.

The clothing at Banana Republic is typically more expensive than that of other Gap Inc. brands. However, the products and in-store shopping experience also feel more luxurious.

I thought the Banana Republic blazer would be worth the investment.

Chloe wears a black blazer with two front pockets over a white button-up shirt. — The blazer from Banana Republic fit me nicely.
Chloe Caldwell

At Banana Republic, I tried on the sculpted suit blazer in black. I loved the fit and silhouette of this piece, and it was much more tailored than the one I tried on at Old Navy. It also provided a more shapely look with a slight cinch at the waistline.

The fabric felt higher quality, but seemed to only vary slightly from that of the Old Navy option. It was made with 49% polyester, 44% recycled polyester, and 7% elastane spandex.

The Banana Republic blazer, which cost $160, was more than three times the price of the Old Navy option. However, considering the significant improvement in overall quality and fit, I didn't think it was a completely outrageous price.

I walked out of both stores empty-handed, but I'd consider going back for the Banana Republic blazer once it goes on sale. After all, a blazer is an investment piece that's worth paying more for.

Read the original article on Business Insider